.
Feedback

UPDATE: CHSD Ends Football Ties with Bellmore-Merrick EMS

Bellmore-Merrick EMS demanded that 50 percent of calls go to them, according to CHSD Physical Education Director Saul Lerner,

After years of working with the Bellmore-Merrick EMS, the Bellmore-Merrick Central High School District will look elsewhere for emergency support during the upcoming football season.

Director of Physical Education Saul Lerner spoke on the issue at Wednesday's board of education meeting at Brookside.

“For the 17 years that I’ve been here, an ambulance from either the local fire department or the Bellmore-Merrick EMS has always been at all of our football games,” Lerner said. “Also, whenever we’ve had an emergency at one of our schools, it’s our policy to call the fire department."

"However, this year, the assistant chief of the Bellmore-Merrick EMS demanded that 50 percent of our emergency calls must go to them, or they would withdraw their services from our football games,” Lerner added.

The alleged demand forced Lerner to make a decision a week before the district’s first football game of the 2012 season.

After conferring with district Superintendent Henry Kiernan and all three CHSD principals, Lerner decided not to change their policy. As a result, Lerner said that Bellmore-Merrick EMS withdrew their football support, which originally covered approximately 50 percent of games played in a season.

“Fortunately, we reached out to the three fire departments that service our games currently,” Lerner said. “One has already answered that they will cover the extra load and I’m awaiting a response from the other two fire districts, but they seemed like they would make every effort to make sure every game was covered.”

Christopher Benes, who's the chief of Bellmore-Merrick EMS, said that no such demand was made and issues arose when he was informed too late of the football schedule.

"They usually send us the football schedule in June, but we didn't get it until a couple of weeks ago," Benes said. "We had already committed to the Merrick Street Fair."

Benes said that he only told Lerner that they couldn't cover one game.

"Neither the board of directors nor I said we weren't going to do the games this year," Benes added. "It was one game ... literally one game."

What do you think of the change in emergency coverage for the district's football games? Tell us in the comments below.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Bellmore Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Christopher Benes September 7, 2012 at 04:02 pm
BMEMS never said it would not do the games this year. Requests to meet with the CHSD Supeintendant by the Bellmore-Merrick EMS have been pending for two weeks with no affirmative answer.
The superintendant might want to know that (1) No threats were ever made. (2) and that concerns with trianers hired by Mr. Lerner are sometimes not qualified and could have gotten a player killed but for BMEMS intercedeing in a game. Should no the superindentant be concernd why Mr. Lerner allowed a Calhoun game to take place and why 12 football players were taken to the hospital last year, when he claims he recoginzed before the Calhoun game that it should not have been played. Further, why he believes the same private trainers he hired somehow substitutes for an advance life support ambulance on scene. If the superindendant does not want to meet with members of the CHSD community then we will meet with the CHSD School Board to discuss our side. Mr. Lerner has said there is no need to have an ambulance at the school games. Is he right? Even if that is the law, do you want your kids to be exposed to injury and have to wait for an ambulance. We don't want to be responsible for anyone hurt or have delay of care. I am not sure Mr. Lerner does.
Zach T September 7, 2012 at 04:19 pm
Also Mr Bennes, if you really deserve enough credit to be called "mr", Youre trying to be a "community" service, startig a fight against the community and our childrens wellbeing just so you can drive your free car, free gas, and free food with our donations, as well as pay your members to sit around? Get a life
Robert September 7, 2012 at 04:38 pm
Please use the correct professional language when address Athletic Trainers. We are not "trainers" that you see in your local sports club or gym. We are nationally board certified health care providers with specific training in sports medicine. Which encompasses: Sport Specific Orthopedic evaluation and diagnosis, Sports Rehab, Preventive Care, and emergency response to Athletic Injuries. Athletic trainers are far more superior trained in dealing with football specific injuries then EMT's. ( I am both a EMT. And a licensed and Certified Athletic trainer who has worked in the high school setting, now I am working in collegiate athletics).
Do not drag the Athletic Training Profession into your duel.
Todd September 7, 2012 at 05:48 pm
Zach - you may be thinking of another department but our members are not paid. Every one of our 60 members are volunteers that commit to weekly shifts and off-shift emergency response. No member, nor officer, nor board member, receives any form of compensation. Further, we only have one Chief's car, a 2007 Charger, which the Chief does not use as his primary vehicle. He does not drive it to work, nor on personal errands, or when transporting his children. We are a community service that does not receive any tax or other public funding. Please get your facts straight before making public accusations.
Zach T September 7, 2012 at 09:21 pm
Hey Todd-
I find it ironic that you tell me not to make assumptions when your own "chief", makes accusations against the school officials. I could care less what you bafoons pretend, but none of my 3 kids will ever step foot in your ambulance, no matter how injured or sick they are
Alan September 7, 2012 at 09:34 pm
And the athletic trainer, and the brilliant Lerner, let 12 kids go to the hospital with hypothermia last season! Is hypothermia a football specific injury? Rob - you may be an excellent athletic trainer but not everyone with that certification is, just like not all EMTs are great EMTs. Heck even the guy that graduates last in medical school is still called doctor. But this isn't about who's stethescope is longer, it's about the kids. Athletic trainers and the emergency guys need to work together.
Michael Ganci (Editor) September 7, 2012 at 09:44 pm
@Alan- Keep it civil please. Cursing will not be tolerated. Thanks for reading.
Jim September 7, 2012 at 09:49 pm
That's a brilliant stance to take.
Alan September 7, 2012 at 09:53 pm
Sorry.
Alan September 7, 2012 at 09:55 pm
Seriously? You're putting your kids health second to an argument about football games? Father of the year.
Michael Ganci (Editor) September 7, 2012 at 10:04 pm
@Alan- Thanks for understanding.
Concerned Citizen September 8, 2012 at 10:46 am
It's inky a matter of time until the state comes down on BMEMS and shuts them down. I do remember an incident where an "assistant chief", and I use that term loosely, almost cost a young lady her vocal cords because of a botched intubation attempt while conscious.
Alan September 8, 2012 at 11:02 pm
Ha! With the millions you get from taxpayers every year, that you spend on beer, food, and racing, you should be covering every football, baseball, softball, soccer, and badmitton game!
James September 9, 2012 at 12:06 am
Sorry wrong department. Not BMEMS
James September 9, 2012 at 12:19 am
Seriously,???? You picked up one game,the same game BMEMS could not make because of its prior commitement to the Merrick Street Fair. Some hero....With your 4 million dollar per year,or is it 5 million dollar budget, you should not be charging anyone for anything.
By the way, I asked, there is no Alan in BMEMS. Way to go Zach T right on the money with your information.
Todd September 9, 2012 at 12:29 am
Sorry to inform you that we do not have any members named Alan.
Stanley Lee September 9, 2012 at 03:14 am
I surely would hope if you make an open accusation like that you could back it up with some facts. I wouldn't want anyone saying that "concerned citizen" was being libelous....
Stanley Lee September 9, 2012 at 03:17 am
Perhaps your thinking of the other departments in the area that give each of the chiefs new trucks to drive all over on our tax dollars?
Zach T September 9, 2012 at 05:57 am
It was the same year that the 17 year old kid crashed the ambulance on Merrick rd in Freeport
Stanley Lee September 9, 2012 at 11:01 am
Zach and anyone else,
A claim like this one is a serious claim! Give proof, or I will assume you have some kind of gripe and are stating nothing more than BS. I could make a blind claim again anyone on a comment board, or I could give details and back them up with facts that can be verified. Put the facts up or you are simply libelous! If by mentioning a crash you are also trying to take a shot against them, read the news, crashes happen daily, big deal.
eddy September 10, 2012 at 01:43 pm
What a bout the cell tower income that was labeled as a 50' antenna for the ems?
I don't remember it being listed as a cell tower.
Michael R. September 10, 2012 at 02:38 pm
Another good point though completely irrelevant. BMEMS was smart enough in the 1990's to convert its then 100 foot radio antenna (built in the 1970's) to a cell site to get more resources to help buy the ambulances, insurances and gas that serve the community. It cost about $175,000 to buy one ambulance and about $50,000 to equip it and about $50,000 a year to run it with a volunteer crew. Since BMEMS does not gets tax revenue like the fire or police, it was pretty wise to marshal all their available resources . Thanks eddy for pointing that out.
Randy September 11, 2012 at 11:44 am
Truth is, BM did something like this several years ago! Because Applebees in Bellmore called the fire department rather than them for emergency calls, the chief made Applebees "Off Limits" as a punishment and crews were told that they could not eat there.
Judy September 11, 2012 at 01:07 pm
Who ever stated you'd only be treated by an EMT? BMEMS has a few career paramedics and over 10 EMT-CC's
The Voice of Reason September 11, 2012 at 01:12 pm
Is it really that unreasonable for the school to consider calling them for emergencies? I don't see the problem here. They could easily have assigned alternating days of who to call.. M/W/F call fire, and give BMEMS Tues and Thurs. Problem solved and this "stethoscope measuring contest" can be done and over with.
eddy September 11, 2012 at 01:21 pm
Meanwhile are they trying to help the community or hurt it. The cell tower could be hurting the community. I don't feel comfortable with it so close to residences.
Un-Concerned Citizen September 11, 2012 at 02:00 pm
http://www.wirelessweek.com/Archives/2005/05/The-Myth-of-Cellular-Tower-Health-Hazards/
Anon Reader September 11, 2012 at 06:09 pm
I had to read Mr. Benes' response about 3 times because of the poor grammar/spelling errors interspersed throughout. This man is a licensed attorney to boot? All I have to say about that is "wow". *shakes head*.
James September 11, 2012 at 09:53 pm
You must be the one that counts the deck chairs on the Titanic as it was sinking.
Randy September 11, 2012 at 09:55 pm
I agree with Anon Reader. Benes' English is so surprisingly bad for an educated individual.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Joe Targove June 16, 2013 at 08:14 am
I'm willing to donate my party place in east Meadow and my dj services for free to help the kids. ..Read More dreamcatcher516@gmail.com joe
Mickey June 10, 2013 at 08:25 am
Natalie. I am so sorry to read this. I too have a little 5 yr. old dog who I love desperately...Read More and I feel your pain. There is another website for an organization that does an amazing job finding lost pets. It's LOSTMYDOGGIE.COM There is a small fee, but they get signs up all over the area and have a phone system set up where everyone in the area of where she was lost gets a PHONE CALL ALERT message to watch for Molly. They leave a phone number and their website address so if anyone has seen her or has her they know where to call. Great system! Check it out! I've never used them, but I HAVE received calls myself recently on 2 separate lost dogs and I've seen the many photos they hung up in my area in Levittown for dogs lost within a few miles of this area. In other words, they DO what they say they will do to help find Molly. Just want you to know what is out there to help you bring Molly home. My grandkids go to school around Grand and Camp Ave. We'll be watching for her! God Bless and good luck! I'm sure she will be returned to you real soon!!
Natalie Molloy June 10, 2013 at 10:14 am
Molly is actually not my dog , however I understandthe feeling of losing a dog and thought it wouldRead More be a good idea to post on the Patch.
Mickey June 10, 2013 at 08:25 pm
GREAT idea!! Post EVERYWHERE possible!! Nice of you to help!