.
Feedback

Town of Hempstead Notebook: Fallout From the 'Disturbing' Animal Shelter Video

A weekly look-in at news in the Town of Hempstead.

The 'Kill the Kitty' Video

On Monday, a nearly 20-year old video was posted on YouTube that depicts Town of Hempstead Animal Shelter employees making obscene gestures, handling a kitten and saying "kill the kitty."

It has been alleged that the voice saying "kill the kitty" on the video was Acting Shelter Director Pat Horan, but a town interview with Horan has been met with an emphatic denial that her voice was on the video.

The Animal Shelter has been plagued by a lawsuit involving alleged abuse and recently underwent changes to improve pet care.

The lawsuit was filed last year by three former volunteer animal rescue workers and states that they were banned from the shelter after “speaking out to shelter employees and town officials about the cruel and inhumane instances of animal abuse and neglect they observed at the shelter.”

The Town's Response to the Video

Within hours of the release of the video Town Supervisor Kate Murray reassigned Horan to the Department of General Services. According to a town spokesperson, Horan currently earns $92,491 in her position.

Hempstead Town Press Secretary Susan Trenkle-Pokalsky called the video “disturbing” and the comments on it “ugly and unacceptable.”

“The town finds the actions contained in the video offensive and is investigating the circumstances surrounding the video,” she said.

Additionally, town officials say it will be conducting a search for an animal shelter director immediately.

Horan was also under scrutiny earlier this year when a media outlet reported she had registered to vote in Nassau County, even though records state she resides in Suffolk County.

A Peaceful Protest

Town of Hempstead residents held a protest across the street from the animal shelter yesterday afternoon. Patch will have a full report on the protest up soon.

Town Board to Meet Tuesday

The Hempstead Town Board has a meeting scheduled for March 8 at 10:30 a.m.

Sandra Rideout March 20, 2011 at 01:41 pm
Reassigned at over 92,000 a year. Ted David could not have said it better. They should all be fired. What a sick bunch of people.
Me March 20, 2011 at 01:58 pm
Heard from a "friend" that there are SEVERAL people in the General Services Dep't. earning big salaries who sit and read the newspaper all day!!!! These are OUR tax $$$ at work.!!!
Felix Procacci March 20, 2011 at 02:12 pm
Pat Horan actually makes well over $100,000 per year. SeethroughNY has her at 118,000 for 2009 and 103,000 for 2010. She also drives a car the Town leases for her.
Sandra Rideout March 20, 2011 at 03:15 pm
I am still seething. I have never written a comment on anything before but this is just horrible. Where did they get their training Abu Ghraib? If this was a retirement home these people would have been fired immediately. Maybe it is time to look into the General Services Dept. I don't mind paying my fair share of taxes but not to support a rubber room for politically connected people.
Famgel March 20, 2011 at 03:45 pm
I agree with everything said above, Kate Murray you will be next to go. Please terminate Pat Horan and get people in there that actually work for the animals.
Paul March 20, 2011 at 04:20 pm
It is interesting that after years of mismanaged money, it takes a 20 year old video to wake people up to the abuses of government as it relates to salaries. The alleged abuses at the shelter is probably just the tip of the iceberg. As a former civil service employee, I have seen firsthand the waste of taxpayer money. But, I have also seen the dedication of many of the workers. A part of the problem lays when government gets fat and lazy and only appeases it's workers certain entitlements to guarantee a strong foundation for re-election. The majority of the blame should be placed on you, the taxpayer, who for the most part could care less what happens in government until something like this nature comes to light. Kate Murray is one of the actors on this stage. Wake up people, get involved, vote and then, maybe, the abuses of political patronage, wasted tax dollars and uncaring workers will be addressed.
Ted D. Gluckman March 20, 2011 at 04:30 pm
You could not have said it better. In the end, WE are to blame. BUT if we care, then time to call on Ms Murray to fix this or step down. First thing she needs to do is can Horan to prove her good faith. Next thing she needs to do is hire an OUTSIDE expert on running animal shelters to take a look at this one and fix it... NOT using Town hacks! Hire new people, fresh blood, and for now make it a NO KILL shelter unless the animals are sick or vicious. Clearly allowing these incompetents now working there to make life and death decisions about animals is foolish. There are many shelters like The Animal Lovers' League (where I volunteer) in Glen Cove that have room for animals that have no home and would otherwise be put down.
catherine oconnell March 20, 2011 at 04:38 pm
If Kate Murray thinks so highly of Horan, then they both should be shown the door! Ted David hit the nail right on the head!
Steve Anchin March 20, 2011 at 04:44 pm
The Town of Hempstead Animal Shelter disgrace is emblematic of the patronage stuffed, corrupt crony government that results from one party government -in this case 110 years of unbroken Republican rule in the Town of Hempstead. The Town is not their personal employment agency for GOP party hacks like Pat Horan ... or Kate Murray, the rest of the elected officials and her management staff. How much lower would our taxes be without all these freeloaders on the Town payroll? This November she and her fellow-Republican Town officials must be go. It's time to "kick the bums out."
Matthew Hogan (Editor) March 20, 2011 at 04:48 pm
We will have a full video of yesterday's Town of Hempstead Animal Shelter protest up Monday morning at 8 a.m.
Scott Clarke March 20, 2011 at 05:06 pm
They can READ?? I didn't know the qualification standards for govt employment had been increased.
Lisa McGovern March 20, 2011 at 06:53 pm
I personally had the honor of seeing the kind of work that 2 of 3 people banned from the shelter do. They helped me tremendously with finding homes for dogs I was no longer. capable of caring for. They are dedicated to helping animals above and beyond anything I have ever seen, I call them angels. That shelter must be doing horrible things to the animals there because there is no other reason that these 2 angels would have been banned from the shelter!!!
Ted D. Gluckman March 20, 2011 at 07:41 pm
Please understand that in a kill shelter they DO do horrible things to animals all the time. They euthanize them solely because they cannot be placed in a loving home. BUT sadly that is acceptable in a kill shelter and we have to work with that. However, in this particular place, it would appear they managed to hire evil, sadistic people who not only were not upset by having to put down perfectly healthy animals, they seemed to thrive on and enjoy their positions as bullies. The people who appear on that video making foolish/obscene gestures and laughing inappropriately have no business working in that environment. If they are stressed out from working in that place, then they need to transfer somewhere else. They CANNOT, however, continue to work there and be heartless, soulless and immature. People who cannot or do not understand the gravity of the situation of working in a kill shelter should not be employed there and should quit or be terminated.
There is no room for low rent jackasses on the Town payroll, whether in the Shelter or in the Supervisor's office.
Tricia March 20, 2011 at 07:49 pm
Anyone who harms a poor defenseless animal should be fired and banned from having an animal in their home or on their premis and should not be allowed to work with animals ever.
Sandra Rideout March 20, 2011 at 09:00 pm
No Clem I don't feel a bit better and your comments show that you are the one that needs to grow up.
Jeanne March 20, 2011 at 09:52 pm
You also show great potential for bullying. Does it make you feel superior to call others pansies? Do you work there by any chance?
cippy March 20, 2011 at 10:12 pm
Clem, those who show concerns for animals, usually have that same concern for their fellow man. You, however, lack that trait for any species. Pansies are beautiful to behold. You my poor Clem must belong to the weed genus..stink weed.
That poor kitten was tortued and made to be terrified in a cruel way. One can only imagine all that has gone on in that place. People are affected by this video because unlike humans, who can help themselves, this poor kitten was at the mercy of imbeciles. There was no mercy. Anyone who values life would be upset.
Jeanne March 21, 2011 at 12:31 am
Well said cippy!
Ted D. Gluckman March 21, 2011 at 12:40 am
Folks, people like Clem live to come on sites like this and incite people. The best thing you can do is not reply. He is an idiot and probably also a sicko... he gets off on your replies and you can stop that by NOT replying. Let it go.
Jeanne March 21, 2011 at 12:57 am
I do get your point but people need to speak up, not shut up. You can't let comments like this go unchallenged. You speak your piece and THEN you ignore.
/\\ /\\ ( >'Y'<) (,,,) (,,,)
Ted D. Gluckman March 21, 2011 at 01:01 am
He's like a flasher. He relies on your reaction to get off. Don't react, he cant get off. Of more consequence is getting a decent manager of the animal shelter and getting Kate to Murray to say uncle.
Rose March 21, 2011 at 02:31 am
I just watched the video for the first time and I was terribly upset by what I saw. Charges should definitely be brought against Pat Horan for allowing things like this to occur, and the "adults" in the video should also be charged with animal abuse, depraved indifference and torture. Maybe someone should do the same to them.
Beth March 21, 2011 at 01:52 pm
I could not agree with Lisa McGovern's comment more. The volunteers who were banned??? are angels. Diane Madden sent me a picture of a pathetic puppy with no fur due to a horrible case of the mange. Guess what would have happened to him in the Town of Hempstead Animal Shelter? Thanks to Diane sending the picture and an S.O.S. to help as she did with hundreds of other animals, a wonderful couple I know adopted this pup. To say he is now gorgeous and thriving would be an understatement. This is what loving volunteers do, they HELP in the mission of Adoption - Not Euthanasia. There are laws to protect people in the rest of the country when they speak out about injustices. Does this not apply to the Town of Hempstead?? I guess if you speak up about horrors and animal cruelty you have witnessed they ban you from entering the shelter. It seems the Town of Hempstead feels the fact that these people were volunteers and not employees protected by their union made them fair game to be treated horribly. Who is being hurt besides the defenseless animals?
Whistleblower laws make it illegal for employers to retaliate in any way, against employees who: •Report employers' violations of whistleblower laws to the proper authorities •Refuse to engage in activities made unlawful by whistleblower laws •Participate in legal proceedings under whistleblower laws We must all speak out to get the good people back in and keep the apathetic and cruel people out.
Rose Burke March 21, 2011 at 03:07 pm
DEMAND TOWN TREASURER, KEVIN CONROY OPEN BOOKS OF SHELTER AT 3/22/11 TOWN MEETING AS TO WHERE PRIVATE FUNDING AND TAXPAYING MONEY HAS GONE, SINCE NOT FOR THE SHELTER, AS PAT HORAN MAKING 100,000 PER YEAR. ALSO FIND A LAWYER TO SEE IF TOWNSHIP AND PAT HORAN CAN BE SUED FOR MISSUSE OF PRIVATE FUNDING AND TAX PAYING MONEY. THE ONLY THING THAT IS GOING TO GET PAT HORAN OUT OF THE SHELTER IS LEGAL ACCOUNTABLILITY. ALSO, KATE MURRAY'S OFFICE CANNOT STATE WHO IS DOING THE INVESTIGATION ON PAT HORAN ALTHOUGH THAT IS WHAT THEY ARE PUTTING OUT TO THE MEETING. IT IS IMPORTANT AT TOWN MEETING TO ASK WHY AND GET LEGAL QUESTIONS ANSERED.
Denise Bond March 21, 2011 at 04:35 pm
I am outraged by this. I live in the same town as Kate Murray and we also go to the same church. You mean to tell me they don't fire these people but merely transfer them. How would they like their pets trated like this. I am sick to my stomach over this. Everyone of the them should be voted out the next election, including Ms. Murray!
Ted D. Gluckman March 21, 2011 at 04:53 pm
Why not take up the subject at Church on Sunday when you see Kate again! Perfect place for her to think more about God's creatures, no?
Denise Bond March 21, 2011 at 05:25 pm
I plan on doing just that!!!! I think it's time to take this to Mangano or our new governor!
Ted D. Gluckman March 21, 2011 at 05:36 pm
I look forward to hearing how that goes. Be polite, but firm. She needs to fire Horan period if she is to have ANY credibility.. and she needs to hire a certified animal shelter administrator from OUTSIDE the political "hackdom" that is Nassau County. Good for you
Danielle March 21, 2011 at 07:27 pm
Alert Hempstead Town Board Meeting March 22nd tues 10:30 am @ Nathan Bennet Pavilion 1 Washington st. Hwmpstead NY Your support is needed. Come out be heard... and as TED stated, please be polite, but FIRM! Please help put an end of the miuse of taxpayer money and the abuse of the animals in thier care. Every person that just shows up can make a difference.
Thomas Cole May 8, 2011 at 09:23 pm
I have been following this since the video first was posted on Youtube and created all the response. I am an "outsider" and am not familiar with the workings of your local government. Aside from those issues, I am writing to commend all of you for being so concerned and caring about the plight of your animals. It is clear this community truly cares. Thank you! ToH - the people - represents what I see growing across the country.
There is a solution to all that ToHAS is not: Shelter Revolution (www.shelterrevolution.org) is the website, the ADOPTION CENTER model is the solution. I hope you will endorse it for ToHAS. A better way for a better future. Basically, this innovative model relies on the No-Kill Equation (NKE), a common-sense 11-step program, to initiate an outward marketing effort. The Adoption Center model complements the NKE by redesigning the facility from a terrible prison to an inviting marketing center where happy animals mingle with customers WITHOUT CAGES! Secondly, it provides a road map to deal with animals not ready for adoption due to behavior issues. Instead of killing, it puts in place the training needed to transform rescuers and fosters into true rehabbers who can deal with these issues in their homes. "Shelters" are not the environment for this work. Sup'r Kate Murray has not responded once to any of the 4 contacts we have sent to her. It's up to you caring people to make this happen. Btw, our work is FREE for the asking!

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Bellmore Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Joe Targove June 16, 2013 at 08:14 am
I'm willing to donate my party place in east Meadow and my dj services for free to help the kids. ..Read More dreamcatcher516@gmail.com joe
Mickey June 10, 2013 at 08:25 am
Natalie. I am so sorry to read this. I too have a little 5 yr. old dog who I love desperately...Read More and I feel your pain. There is another website for an organization that does an amazing job finding lost pets. It's LOSTMYDOGGIE.COM There is a small fee, but they get signs up all over the area and have a phone system set up where everyone in the area of where she was lost gets a PHONE CALL ALERT message to watch for Molly. They leave a phone number and their website address so if anyone has seen her or has her they know where to call. Great system! Check it out! I've never used them, but I HAVE received calls myself recently on 2 separate lost dogs and I've seen the many photos they hung up in my area in Levittown for dogs lost within a few miles of this area. In other words, they DO what they say they will do to help find Molly. Just want you to know what is out there to help you bring Molly home. My grandkids go to school around Grand and Camp Ave. We'll be watching for her! God Bless and good luck! I'm sure she will be returned to you real soon!!
Natalie Molloy June 10, 2013 at 10:14 am
Molly is actually not my dog , however I understandthe feeling of losing a dog and thought it wouldRead More be a good idea to post on the Patch.
Mickey June 10, 2013 at 08:25 pm
GREAT idea!! Post EVERYWHERE possible!! Nice of you to help!