.
Feedback

Town Animal Shelter Criticized in Audit

New York State Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli releases findings of investigation into fiscal operations at Wantagh facility.

High operational costs, a mismanagement of overtime expenses and poor record-keeping were among the findings of a recent audit on the Town of Hempstead Animal Shelter in Wantagh, State Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli announced Friday.

The audit into the shelter on 3320 Beltagh Ave. in Wantagh was undertaken by DiNapoli’s office after requests by town residents and Nassau County District Attorney Kathleen Rice. A full report of the audit can be found by clicking here

“The shelter’s finances and animal care issues have long been a concern of town residents,” said DiNapoli in a statement. “Our audit has shed much-needed light on several of the problems that plague the operation of this facility. The shelter’s finances need to be more closely scrutinized to ensure that animals receive proper care and taxpayers aren’t paying excessive costs." 

DiNapoli said the audit showed that the shelter’s operational costs were higher than animal shelters in the Towns of Islip and Brookhaven in every category reviewed including total costs and expenses per animal processed. In 2010, the T

Town of Hempstead Animal Shelter’s total salary costs were $2.7 million compared to $820,076 in Islip and $1.5 million in Brookhaven, the audit showed. The average salary for the shelter’s 32 full-time employees was $79,247, according to the audit.

The Town of Hempstead issued a statement in response to the audit results emphasizing that the report shows no findings of mistreating animals or providing substandard care for animals at the shelter.

Hempstead officials also emphasized that they have already implemented some of recommendations from the audit including putting shelter operations into the general fund of the town’s budget as well as addressing operation costs. 

A portion of the Town of Hempstead statement reads: “By adopting the state comptroller’s accounting methodology, the 2013 town budget reflects a $3.37 million reduction in the animal shelter’s budget. Finally, the town has already taken steps to address the comptroller’s recommendations in the areas of cost control and operational oversight. Specifically, computerization upgrades, the implementation of a cost allocation analysis and the adoption of more stringent operational procedures are making the shelter more efficient and cost effective.”

Other findings from the audit were: 
  • The shelter did not have formal procedures on how to manage, document, approve and verify overtime worked. The town paid $359,408 for 8,860 overtime hours worked at the shelter from 2007 to 2011. The overtime hours reviewed by auditors could not be adequately justified.
  • The town-wide general fund inappropriately charged the shelter $3.5 million in 2010 and $2.6 million in 2011 for administrative cost charge-backs. 
  • Administrative costs charged to various departments did not reflect the actual services received. 
  • Supervisory staff did not periodically review the office copy of issued receipt forms, and did not investigate and document in writing any variances in information, gaps or missing receipt forms. 
“While these problems do not rise to the level of criminality, the comptroller’s review found systemic problems that compromise the public’s confidence and could detract from the shelter’s overall mission and responsibility to its animals and the community,” said Rice in a statement. “While our investigation found no criminal abuse or neglect of the shelter’s animals, both the animals and taxpayers will be well-served if the town promptly adopts the comptroller’s recommendations.” 

This story was written by Andrew Coen.

MORE TOP NEWS


Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Bellmore Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Loading comments ...
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
truth May 19, 2013 at 09:11 pm
You are going to do something that even Cuomo won't touch...pensions? Well, thank you forRead More recognizing the real problem that faces the taxpayers but how will you address the problem and not just promise?
Dan DeLilla May 18, 2013 at 10:40 pm
So Lu Scala never had any children so it might be safe to say you have never been to a PTA meetingRead More or a School Board meeting or a budget presentation so then you would have no idea how the money is spent good or bad. I'm sorry that your neighbors make more than you but like anything else you get what you pay for there are educational requirements for teaching and administration jobs, I'm sure you would be happy if all the school personnel could be replaced by minimum wage earners or better yet we could close all the schools after all you have been out of school for 40 years so you don't need them anymore, but thats not how it works. Why is always the uninformed that speak loudest and longest?
Lu Scala May 17, 2013 at 08:49 am
I never had any kids.. and am the last kid who went to to the Bellmore Merrick school system.....itsRead More been almost 40 years since I was a Mempham grad..and it is very disharting to hear that my many many high tax dollars..are not enought for these kids I have been sororting all these years!!! Who is getting all the money??? Its all bull.. aI live inbetween teachers.. how is it they can afford high end cars, housekeepers, landscapers, ect??????... the money is being spent in the WRONG WAYS TO THE TEACHERS, AND MOST OF ALL THE ADMISTRATION, THE SCHOOL BOARD ECT... I AM CALLING FOR A MASSIVE AUDIT AND GET0 per year.. they afe not worth any more then that.. THE MONEY BACK FROM ANYONE WHO WAS PAID MORE THEN $75,00....
patti May 16, 2013 at 08:28 pm
A bit of a surprise considering kids come home with a supply list a mile long (and average $40-$75).
Michael Ganci (Editor) May 14, 2013 at 01:34 pm
Can you edit above and add photo? Then I will post to top news! Thanks! MG